ELDEN RING: A therapeutic journey

Level 165, 269 hours and 38 minutes. It was quite a journey until here, and now journey 2 has begun.

As much as I hated it in the first 20 hours, I came to realize that Elden Ring is the most therapeutic game that I have ever played in the last 46 years that I have been playing computer/video games.

It is the only game that I have ever found in my entire life that, no matter how stressful, hard or bleak life might have become, Elden Ring manages to demand and get my full, undivided focus and attention while I’m playing it.

While playing other games, my mind always kept pondering about whatever real life problem I needed to tackle.

But not so while playing Elden Ring.

That is the game’s real magic:

It takes your entire mind away from everything else.

Not by cheaply distracting you and giving your brain some intellectual chewing gum.

It does so by giving your mind an endless series of tough challenges to solve and a colossal ruined, collapsed, but still awe-inspiring world to explore.

With every defeat that you endure in the game, you learn something.

And once you’ve endured enough defeats, you will know how overcome the obstacle in your path.

And then you encounter the next challenge, usually tougher than the one before.

A long series of frustration gets followed by a short victory dopamine rush, only to get immediately crushed by the next defeat.

There never is a safe moment in this game.

After over 260 hours in the game, my Level 165 Wretch got killed by a Lesser Bloodhound Knight.

Twice in a row.

I went back at him with a vengeance.

The game masterfully plays piano on your brain’s chemistry.

You get addicted to the rhythm of the relentless grind in this game.

All the unforgiving enemies and puzzles in Elden Ring have their own individual rhythms, too, and in order to progress you need to learn how to dance to them:

When to hit, when to parry, when to throw a spell.

When to dodge, when to roll.

When to retreat.

When to go in for the kill.

You need a unique combination of fully awoken primeval instincts and focused intellectual capacity to succeed in this game.

Elden Ring is a one of a kind experience that only comes once in a century.

I doubt that anybody will ever be able to top or even repeat this, not even the chief game designer of Elden Ring, Hidetaka Miyazaki, himself.

SHADOW OF THE ERDTREE is no fun to play

I think I now spent over 30 hours in the Elden Ring DLC and it’s time for another rather depressing summary.

The Elden Ring DLC Shadow of the Erdtree offers a lot of copy & paste content from the base game – and the dungeons and towers in the base game were already mostly identical copies of each other. It feels like the only had one Socialist architect building the place. The DLC is even worse in that aspect.

The DLC also does not have those moments where you feel awe-struck like you did in the base game when you, for example, discovered that gigantic underground city; the elevator rides alone in that place where something else.

Then I’ve always hated boss fights in games and find them to be an absolutely moronic design concept. I’ve beaten all bosses in the base game, despite my hate for the entire “boss” idea. The bosses were tough, but you could figure out how to deal with them.

In the DLC… they’ve changed the bosses into lightning fast creatures that I, being 56 years old, simply cannot compete with on speed alone and I decided to not bother anymore.

The other more objective problem with them also is: Those bosses are clearly designed for pure melee fights – and my character is built to use brains over brawns. When you prefer using magic instead of swords, those enemies are so fast and the arenas so small that they will kill you before you can even cast a single spell. That is broken game design right there.

I’m saying all of this as someone who in his first ever souls-like experience decided to play as a Wretch, and I grinded my Wretch up to level 165 over the course of 250 hours.

I became Elden Lord.

I’ve earned my place at the table.

Just like the base game, the DLC also suffers from severely poor design choices, but they are more obvious and more painful in the DLC – and they ruin the experience.

You can feel that the DLC was made after the base game and it is intentionally ridiculously more difficult than the base game.

The problem with that, however, is that the DLC is intended to be played… before you become Elden Lord and finish the game. And from that perspective, the entire design of the DLC just makes no sense whatsoever: Every tiny boss in that DLC is harder to beat than the Elden Beast.

To add insult to injury, exploration and fighting enemies is absolutely unrewarding in Shadow of the Erdtree. The item drops are uninteresting and mostly useless and because of that you quickly start asking yourself why you’re even going through the pain of fighting your way through those mazes.

And no, there also is no story to be found in the DLC either, despite an increased number of NPCs who are willing to exchange a few sentences with you. Everybody just wants to find Miquella for whatever reason.

The DLC feels like an awkward afterthought and Shadow Of The Erdtree simply is no fun to play, no matter how great its general production quality is.

You’re much better off replaying the base game.

UPDATE:

As per usual, not long after I had written this, I defeated two bosses in a row, including Rellana. Then I managed to reach phase II of the boss fight with Messmer a couple of times. But I didn’t enjoy any of that – and decided to start “Journey 2”.

In Journey 2 you start ridiculously overpowered (in my case as a level 165 Wretch) and mop the floor with all the bosses that on your first playthrough gave you a really hard time.

That’s fun for five minutes, but then it just feels… wrong.

I think the only way to replay the game from start is… Well, as a level 1 Wretch, of course.