Elden Ring: Defeating Malenia

As per usual, not long after I had posted my last rant about Elden Ring and its boss fights, I defeated Malenia.

In the same run, I also defeated that legendary alien boss underground and I also defeated the Black Knife ring leader and added Black Knife Tiche to my collection of summons.

How did the latter happen?

Because I was following some YouTube comments that Black Knife Tiche could on her own defeat Melania.

And that legendary alien creature just was on the way to get there. I had already found it in a previous run but couldn’t beat it. This time… I successfully dispatched it at the first try; not because I’m that ridiculously good (I’m absolutely not), but because my character was now strong enough to take on that enemy – and to survive the hits that creature deals out.

Anyway, Malenia.

After this, we will never talk about her again. Ever.

Elden Ring: Malenia

Malenia is the Nemesis of Elden Ring players.

Technically, she is a boss that you do not need to defeat in order to finish the game.

I actually only tried to engage with her after I had already finished the base game and defeated the Elden Beast – the boss that you must defeat in order to bring the main game to an end.

Malenia has a very unique feature that makes her the toughest boss in the game: With every hit that she lands on you, she regains health.

And she is as fast as a whirl wind and can land many, many hits within a single attack.

Sure, she has a few weaknesses.

If you manage to hit her, she might be stunned for a second.

She cannot withstand attacks that cause blood loss very well, and she is also not resistant to fire.

She is the absolute dream boss of all “git gud” basement dwellers, because she is so hard to defeat and that crowd made it their collective lives’ mission to brag about how they defeat her in less than two minutes. Of course alone, without the help of summons, with just a standard melee weapon. They’re the tough guys, you know. The self-proclaimed gamer master race. With nothing else in their lives worth talking about. They’re the toxic community of Elden Ring and all Souls-like games and the reason why most sane people very rightfully so stay miles away from these games.

Malenia was designed for these people.

And catering to this crowd will eventually turn out to become a huge commercial problem for From Software, the studio that makes these games. Because they will lose all other paying customers along the way and only have the obnoxious crowd left that will never be satisfied with anything. A lesson that can easily be observed with Hollywood and all Western game studios that catered to the cries and demands of the woke crowd. Just look at their financial numbers and you will know how well that worked out for them.

But well, here we are.

So, Malenia.

I don’t belong to the “git gud” crowd, so I already know that I will never be able to defeat her all on my own.

But the game has a mechanic called “summons”; you can actually summon some ghost/spirit support.

Maybe five skeleton warriors with huge shields?

On hand, they work miracles against Melania and can actually keep her cornered. The big problem: Melania can endlessly land hits on their shields, and those hits also regenerate her health. As awesome as those skeleton warriors are, that makes them not a very good choice for this battle, because their approach to battle keeps their enemy unintentionally alive.

Instead, a clone of myself might be the better option for this battle – and the Mimic Tear gives me exactly that; a copy of my character with the exact same equipped tools and weapons.

Elden Ring boss battles usually have two phases, with a cutscene between them.

With a second sword, phase I of the Malenia battle becomes manageable and I reach the cutscene in which Malenia lies on the floor, seemingly defeated, maybe even dead.

And here comes the idiotic part:

Instead of making sure that she is finished off, my character decides to… watch the trees instead.

And to absolutely no-one’s surprise, that was all the time she needed to recover and come back even stronger.

Now isn’t that a “fun” design?

First you have to suffer through some idiocy nobody, and I mean not even the dumbest human being in existence, would ever do in real life: Watching trees instead of making sure that the enemy who wanted to kill is actually dead. That shit only happens in idiotic Hollywood screenplays, but never in the real world.

But no, my character decides to do that, so that the toughest enemy in the game has a chance to come back at us with a vengeance.

She still recovers health after every hit that she lands, she’s still brutally fast – and now she even has wings and can strike you from the air.

Tell me, why didn’t they also make her completely invincible for, let’s say, the first ten minutes of the battle? Or was that planned for a phase III that got scratched in the last minute because at least one person in charge at From Software still had some sanity left?

The good news is that most of the time Malenia focuses on my Mimic first.

The bad news is that in phase II, she will kill my Mimic very quickly.

And the death sigh of my Mimic is the GAME OVER signal for me. Malenia will then make quick work of me.

I have always hated boss fights in every game that I’ve played in the last… almost fifty years.

Boss fights are a completely moronic design concept.

It’s like telling the approaching American and Russian army that with all their might, Hitler alone might be able to completely obliterate them.

It doesn’t get any more stupid than this, right?

Well, maybe you should play Wolfenstein: Spear of Destiny first, then we can come back to this discussion.

There are other ways to create enormous challenges that players need to overcome in order for a story to progress or to reach the end of a game without becoming ridiculously annoying.

But no, there’s always some kind of an idiotic boss fight.

Always.

Because, let’s face it, most game designers lack the creativity to come up with something else.

Boss fights are a too-well established cop-out in the gaming industry.

I think I speak for a lot of gamers when I say this:

I’m playing this game to explore and to have an escape from an already annoying job life with long commutes and endless meetings.

Not to get frustrated and annoyed.

This entire boss fight game design does not respect our time or the situations of our real lives and it plain and simply sucks rocks.

Thank you for nothing. Especially for not listening to the majority of your paying customers.