Elden Ring: Cheesing a boss and related issues

This post started its life as a comment under a YouTube video in which somebody, well, made his own remarks about comments and negative recommendations he found on Steam about the game.

Just like the Linux community, the Elden Ring community suffers from a loud and annoying basement dweller group of people that treat “their” favorite piece of software like a radical religion.

“Cheesing” is basement dweller talk for “we don’t want other players to use hard-earned, legitimate game mechanics to beat a boss; we want them to only use a tooth pick to fight dragons and demi-gods; it’s the only ‘right’ way to play the game!”

Unless you’re exploiting obvious bugs and glitches in the game, there is no such thing as cheesing.

Whatever is in the game is in there BY DESIGN.

Yes, that includes the foxhole through which you can kill Commander Niall without even entering his arena – the developers positioned him exactly there for a reason, and they also put that foxhole there for a reason. It’s not a glitch, it’s design.

All that being said: Boss fights are a god-awful concept since the invention of computer games.

I’m 56 and have been playing computer games for more than 43 years and I’ve always hated that stuff in games – despite the fact that, when I cared enough for the game, I’ve always beaten its bosses.

And yes, I’ve also beaten Malenia, the Elden Beast, Radahn, Mohg, Rykard and whoever else crawled around the Elden Ring base game.

Beating these bosses is not really about “gitting gud” – it’s about using your brains instead of your brawns and it’s also about understanding the character that you play and playing this character to its strengths and abilities.

My Wretch killed the Elden Beast with the Crystal Sword – that’s it. Why did it work? Because this was the one sword my Wretch could keep hitting the beast with without running out of Stamina while staying close to the Beast on Torrent.

None of the YouTube tip videos worked for my Wretch.

None.

The same with Melania: My Wretch and the Blasphemous Sword wiped her out.

Again, none of the glorious tip videos worked.

The only YouTube video that really worked was the one for Commander Niall where what you call a “cheese” was shown: Using the foxhole to shoot arrows at him until he drops.

As far as I am concerned, it’s obvious that this option was there by design: The developers hid a lot of alternative solutions and bypasses in the game to give the players a choice, and I’m willing to bet that this was one of them.

Now what about all those bad reviews of the game on Steam and other places?

Actually, they’re all correct.

Elden Ring has a gigantic amount of design flaws and it’s also an extremely imbalanced game.

The game is hard simply BECAUSE – for reputation and marketing reasons. Not because it makes the game any better.

Elden Ring does not know how to tell a story or even how to build a quest that makes any sense or that you could follow without reading up on it in some WIKI.

These are the parts where game simply is broken and where the entire design flat-out FAILS.

Lore is not a substitute for a story.

Random encounters with no predictable logic or surrounding story that actually hints at the next plot point and location do not make a quest line.

Letting the players come up with some story AFTERWARDS to make sense of that sub-plot is not story telling – it’s crappy design and not knowing how to tell an interactive story.

After 240 hours in the Tarnished Edition of the game and having completed the game and having seen the endtitles, I could not for the life of me tell you what this whole game was even about.

Nada.

Zippo.

The game did not give me ANYTHING to stitch a meaningful story together.

Not that Elden Ring is a game where you actually care about any of that – it’s basically like DOOM in that regard: Nobody ever cared about a story in the original DOOM, and its creators knew that and were very honest about it.

Sure, Elden Ring drops tons of lore through its sceneries on the player, but even that does not tell a meaningful story.

People filled WIKIs with what they BELIEVE Elden Ring’s story is. But those WIKIs are nothing but the wild interpretations of what some players think they saw in the game. None of that stuff is official canon – it’s users telling their own Elden Ring interpretation, and some of them were then declared “official”.

But the reality of Elden Ring is: The game has no story.

None.

The only story you might find in Elden Ring is the one that you, the player, creates through her or his own actions.

And now queue all the people screaming “but George R.R. Martin worked with From Software on…”

No, he didn’t.

George R.R. Martin was paid to write a background story on what had happened in that world roughly around 5000 years before the time in which the actual game plays, which in part explains why that world is in the state it’s in when you enter the game.

That’s all.

He didn’t even really know what the game would be called at that time.

So much for story, lore, background story and George R.R. Martin’s actual involvement.

All of those flaws make it easy to absolutely hate Elden Ring.

But then, there is that highly contagious Elden Ring “bug”:

If you catch that bug, literally every other game will feel absolutely stale in comparison. Because there is no extreme challenge in those other games that could compete with what Elden Ring throws at you.

You will no longer accept the hand-holding of other games.

You want to roam an unforgiving, insane world and do whatever the heck it is you now want to do.

You got used to the fact that everything that your eyes can see can be visited and explored.

After dozens of hours, you have learned that every challenge in the game can be overcome when you just stick to your character’s means and find a strategy that works for your character. This makes it the perfect game to play when your personal life has crumbled into pieces and you can barely hold it together anymore: Elden Ring is a solvable problem, and the remains of your sanity can hold on to that.

Despite all the brutal fights, this game ultimately rewards brains over brawns.

And it’s near impossible to find any other game that keeps your mind as occupied and focused on it as Elden Ring does.

This is what makes Elden Ring the Laphroaig of computer games. It’s an acquired taste. But once you’ve grown to like that taste, everything else feels like a stale compromise.

Still.

We will never talk about Malenia again.

Ever.